Courts and Jails

The Issue

The overuse of jails is one of the greatest drivers of over-incarceration in the United States.

  • There are nearly 12 million local jail admissions every year, which is almost 20 times the number of prison admissions.
  • Many non-violent offenders are jailed for the inability to pay and jailing those that are not flight risks or threats to public safety results in social and economic costs to families.
  • A lack of mental health and substance abuse treatment in jails and jail populations show an over-representation of people of color.

Table of Contents

The Issue

About the Safety and Justice Challenge

Resources

News & Announcements

NPR's All Things Considered interview (February 13, 2021) on the challenges and successes involved in the work to Rethink Jails

Follow NCSC

About the Safety and Justice Challenge


Across the country, courts and other criminal justice partners are looking at ways to identify the drivers of over-incarceration and engage a diverse set of stakeholders to determine ways to improve local systems.

The Safety and Justice Challenge (SJC) provides support to local leaders from across the country as they rethink jails with strategies that safely reduce jail populations and eliminate ineffective, inefficient, and unfair practices.

As a Strategic Ally to the Challenge, NCSC works with state court leaders and national judicial organizations to build awareness of this initiative and provide courts with resources and strategies they can use to improve effective use of jails and promote the need for jail reform.

The Challenge Network

Fifty-one cities and counties, across 32 states, are modeling and inspiring reform as part of the SJC. Explore the map below to learn more about who’s involved and what they’re doing.

Partners and Strategic Allies

Partners and Strategic Allies in the Safety and Justice Challenge help implement this innovative work. Partners are organizations that provide Challenge Network sites with technical assistance, data analysis, and performance measurement. Strategic Ally organizations help the initiative communicate with important stakeholder groups whose support is needed.

Resources

Evidence-Based Court Strategies for Effective Criminal Caseflow Management (December 2021)

Fostering efficient criminal case processing can improve the justice experience for people impacted by pretrial and sentencing decisions. Shorter case processing times can shorten pretrial detention, limit collateral consequences for people awaiting case resolution in the community, and prevent other court interventions (e.g., bench warrants) during the pretrial period. With these practices in mind, courts can work to understand local case processing impacts on people and how best to tailor their policies and practices to improve efficiency and effectiveness. This brief summarizes seven strategies for improving criminal caseflow management for court leaders.

Legal Frameworks Governing Pretrial Release and Detention: Tracking Developments in California (October 2021)

In 2020, the National Center for State Courts published a White Paper on Pretrial Preventive Detention. The White Paper was prepared under the guidance of a Work Group established by the Conference of Chief Justices and Conference of State Court Administrators and reviewed the use of pretrial preventive detention in five jurisdictions: District of Columbia, New Jersey, New Mexico, Arizona, and California. The paper summarized the pretrial detention provisions in the five jurisdictions and reviewed the implementation challenges that the jurisdictions had faced, and the lessons learned. This brief provides an update on developments in California since that time, as of October 2021.

COVID-19 and Pretrial Practices: A Judicial Roundtable (October 2020)
COVID-19 and Pretrial Practices: A Pretrial Executives Roundtable (November 2020)

Advancing Pretrial Policy and Research (APPR), in partnership with the National Center for State Courts (NCSC), invited a group of state court judges and a group of pretrial executives to participate in virtual Judicial and Pretrial Executives Roundtable discussions about the impact of COVID-19 on the pretrial practices in their respective jurisdictions. These two briefs summarize key points from those discussions.

White Paper on Pretrial Preventive Detention and Appendix (February 2020)

The leader­ship of the Conference of Chief Justices and Conference of State Court Administrators established the CCJ/COSCA Work Group on Preventive Detention to inform and guide the development of this White Paper by the National Center for State Courts. This White Paper examines issues raised by scholars, civil rights and pretrial justice advocates, and court leaders through an analysis of statutory or judicial authority for preventive detention in Arizona, California, the District of Columbia, New Jersey, and New Mexico.  It also discusses implementation challenges and lessons learned in the four of these jurisdic­tions that are in various stages of implementation. The purpose of the White Paper is to provide guidance to state court leaders in leading and responding effectively to legislative actions to authorize or expand the use of preventive detention in their states, as well as in developing court rules on preventive detention that both protect the community and maximize individual liberty during the pretrial process.

Evidence-Based Judicial Decision Making Curriculum Toolkit (February 2020)

NCSC developed the Evidence-Based Judicial Decision Making Curriculum Toolkit in response to requests for information about pretrial and sentencing practices affecting persons facing potential local jail sentences. It is based on NCSC’s Evidence-Based Sentencing curriculum, originally developed in 2007, when the Conference of Chief Justices called for the adoption of state sentencing and corrections policies based on “evidence-based practices,” those shown through research to be effective in reducing recidivism.

The Toolkit is available here and includes the following:

  1. Introduction to the Toolkit: a description of the purpose of the curriculum and considerations for delivering it.
  2. Presentation materials: a PowerPoint slide deck with faculty notes and a complete list of references cited in the faculty notes.
  3. Handouts & other demonstrative materials: sample sentencing scenarios, video clips, and other supplementary materials that may be used in the delivery of the curriculum.
  4. Companion briefs: four companion briefs that summarize current research and best practices. The briefs address effective court responses to persons with mental disorders, persons with substance use disorders, persons charged with Driving Under the Influence (DUI), and persons charged with Domestic Violence (DV) offenses.

State Activities to Advance Pretrial Justice Reform (January 2020)

Between May 2016 and November 2018, with SJC support, the Conference of Chief Justices (CCJ) and Conference of State Court Administrators (COSCA) hosted a series of regional Pretrial Justice Reform Summits. This brief summarizes activities state have taken to advance reform since attending the summits.


Safety + Justice Challenge Resource Library
[Full Library]

Vera Institute, A Toolkit for Jail Decarceration in Your Community
[Full Report]

National League of Cities, Reimagining Public Safety: A Toolkit for Cities and Towns
[Full Report]

National League of Cities, A Path Towards Safe and Equitable Cities: Recommendations from the NLC
[Full Report]

Race and Prosecutorial Diversion: What we know and what can be done
[Full Report]

Reducing the Misuse and Overuse of Jails in Safety and Justice Challenge Sites
[Interim Progress Report]

Reducing the Misuse and Overuse of Jails in Safety + Justice Challenge Sites

Jail Decarceration and Public Safety: Preliminary Findings from the Safety and Justice Challenge
[Full Report]

The Impact of COVID-19 on Crime, Arrests, and Jail Populations
[Full Report]

Bail Reform in San Francisco: Pretrial release and intensive supervision increased after Humphrey
[Policy Brief]

Jail Population Trends During COVID-19
[Full Report]
Jail Population
Dollars and Sense in Cook County [Full Report]

Dollars and Sense

Implementation Guide for Prosecutorial Performance indicators
[Full Report]

In the Shadows: A Review of the Research on Plea Bargaining [Fact Sheet] [Full Report]

Cover of In the Shadow

The Present and Future of AI in Pretrial Risk Assessment Instruments [Executive Summary] [Full Report]

THE PRESENT AND FUTURE OF AI IN PRE-TRIAL RISK ASSESSMENT INSTRUMENTS

Pretrial Risk Assessment Tools: A Primer for Judges, Prosecutors, and Defense Attorneys [Executive Summary] [Full Report]

Table of Contents

The Issue

About the Safety and Justice Challenge

Resources

News & Announcements

NPR's All Things Considered interview (February 13, 2021) on the challenges and successes involved in the work to Rethink Jails

Follow NCSC